Supreme Court Adjourns Yasin Malik’s Trial Transfer Hearing to April 4
New Delhi 07 March 2025: The Supreme Court on Friday adjourned to April 4 the hearing on a plea filed by the CBI to transfer trial against jailed JKLF chief Yasin Malik and other co-accused in two cases from Jammu and Kashmir to Delhi. A bench of Justices Abhay S Oka and Ujjal Bhuyan deferred the matter as Solicitor General Tushar Mehta was not available.
During the hearing, Malik appeared before the court through video-conferencing. He requested the court to post the matter after Ramzan to which the bench agreed. The top court had earlier directed Malik to appear before it through video-conferencing on March 7 It was informed that the Jammu sessions court was “well-equipped” with the video-conferencing system enabling the virtual examination.
The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) sought the transfer of the trials in the 1989 case of the kidnapping of Rubaiya Sayeed, daughter of former union minister Mufti Mohammed Sayeed, and the 1990 Srinagar shootout case, from Jammu to New Delhi. The top court previously directed the registrar general of the Jammu and Kashmir High Court to ensure proper video-conferencing facilities at the Jammu special court while hearing two cases against Malik and others.
The top court on December 18, last year, gave six accused two weeks to respond to the CBI’s plea to transfer the trial of the cases. The plea is over the two cases in which four Indian Air Force personnel were killed on January 25, 1990 in Srinagar and the abduction which took place on December 8, 1989. Malik, chief of the proscribed JKLF, is facing trial in both cases. The top court was hearing a CBI plea against the September 20, 2022 order of a Jammu trial court directing Malik, serving a life term in Tihar jail, to be produced before it physically to cross-examine prosecution witnesses in the abduction case.
The CBI said Malik was a threat to national security and couldn’t be allowed to be taken outside the Tihar jail premises. Rubaiya, who was freed five days after her abduction when the then BJP-backed V P Singh government at the Centre released five terrorists in exchange, now lives in Tamil Nadu. She is a prosecution witness for the CBI, which took over the case in the early 1990s. Malik has been lodged in Tihar jail after he was sentenced by a special NIA court in May 2023 in a terror-funding case.
Reason for Adjournment
A bench of Justices Abhay S Oka and Ujjal Bhuyan deferred the matter as Solicitor General Tushar Mehta was not available. During the hearing, Yasin Malik appeared before the court through video-conferencing and requested the court to post the matter after Ramzan, to which the bench agreed.
Background of the Cases
The CBI seeks to transfer the trials in two significant cases:
- 1989 Kidnapping Case: The kidnapping of Rubaiya Sayeed, daughter of former union minister Mufti Mohammed Sayeed.
- 1990 Srinagar Shootout Case: The killing of four Indian Air Force personnel on January 25, 1990, in Srinagar.
Malik, chief of the proscribed JKLF, is facing trial in both cases. The CBI has cited Malik’s national security threat as a reason for transferring the trials from Jammu to New Delhi.
Previous Court Directives
The Supreme Court had earlier directed Malik to appear before it through video-conferencing on March 7. It was informed that the Jammu sessions court was “well-equipped” with the video-conferencing system, enabling the virtual examination.
CBI’s Plea
The CBI sought the transfer of the trials from Jammu to New Delhi, citing delays and national security concerns. The top court previously directed the registrar general of the Jammu and Kashmir High Court to ensure proper video-conferencing facilities at the Jammu special court while hearing the two cases against Malik and others.
Malik’s Current Status
Yasin Malik has been lodged in Tihar jail after being sentenced by a special National Investigation Agency (NIA) court in May 2023 in a terror-funding case. The CBI argued that Malik was a threat to national security and couldn’t be allowed to be taken outside the Tihar jail premises.
Rubaiya Sayeed’s Role
Rubaiya Sayeed, who was freed five days after her abduction when the then BJP-backed V P Singh government at the Centre released five terrorists in exchange, now lives in Tamil Nadu. She is a prosecution witness for the CBI, which took over the case in the early 1990s.
Bottom-Line
The Supreme Court’s decision to adjourn the hearing to April 4, 2025, reflects the complexities and sensitivities surrounding the cases involving Yasin Malik. The transfer of trials from Jammu to New Delhi remains a contentious issue, with national security concerns at the forefront.