Kashmir InFocus
Beyond headlines, into lives: News that matters to you
Live Desk November 16, 2026

Kishtwar SPO Killings: Congress Raises ‘Mistaken Identity’ Question, BJP Hits Back; Families Demand CBI Probe

Kishtwar SPO Deaths Spark Political Storm: Karra Seeks Probe, Sunil Sharma Rejects Claim

Kishtwar SPO Deaths Spark Political Storm: Karra Seeks Probe, Sunil Sharma Rejects Claim

By: Javid Amin | November 16, 2026

The killing of two Special Police Officers in Kishtwar has triggered a major political controversy, with Congress chief Tariq Hameed Karra demanding an impartial investigation into the possibility of mistaken identity, while BJP leader Sunil Sharma has rejected the allegation. But questions raised by the victims’ families about their deployment, security arrangements and the circumstances of their deaths have brought the police administration under fresh scrutiny.

KISHTWAR: The killing of two Special Police Officers (SPOs) in the remote Dachhan area of Jammu and Kashmir’s Kishtwar district has become more than a security investigation. It has developed into a political confrontation involving the Congress, BJP and National Conference, while the families of the deceased are demanding an independent probe and answers from the administration.

The controversy intensified after Jammu and Kashmir Pradesh Congress Committee president Tariq Hameed Karra questioned the circumstances surrounding the deaths of Babi Chand and Rashpal Kumar. He called for investigators to examine every possible angle, including whether the two personnel were mistakenly identified as militants and fired upon by security forces.

The BJP strongly rejected the suggestion. Leader of Opposition Sunil Sharma accused Karra of spreading misleading information and attempting to shift responsibility from suspected militants to the Army and other security personnel.

However, the dispute has taken a more complicated turn. Even BJP leaders have publicly questioned the police deployment arrangements and the decision to send the two SPOs through difficult forest terrain to an Army post in the neighbouring Marwah area.

Meanwhile, the families have demanded a Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) inquiry, arguing that the circumstances of the killings and the security arrangements in their remote village need independent examination.

At the heart of the controversy are several unanswered questions: Who killed the two SPOs? Why were they sent on the particular assignment? What happened during their journey through the forest? And why were their service weapons missing when their bodies were recovered?

How the two SPOs went missing

The deceased have been identified as Babi Chand, 57, and Rashpal Kumar, 45. Both belonged to Kiyar village in the Dachhan area of Kishtwar and were attached to the Special Operations Group (SOG) of Jammu and Kashmir Police.

According to reports, the two personnel went missing on Wednesday, November 11, while travelling towards a Temporary Operational Base (TOB) in the Dharna-Marwah area. They were reportedly assigned to assist personnel deployed at the base.

When they failed to reach their destination, concerns grew among security agencies and their families. A search operation was subsequently launched in the difficult mountainous terrain.

Their bullet-riddled bodies were recovered from a forested area on Thursday, November 12, bringing an end to the search but opening a series of questions about the circumstances of their deaths.

The service weapons they were carrying were also missing. Reports identified the firearms as an INSAS rifle and a .303 rifle, along with magazines and ammunition.

The missing weapons became an important part of the investigation. Security officials suspect that the attackers may have taken them away, strengthening the militant-involvement theory.

The Indian Express reported that the two SPOs had come under fire while travelling through the forested mountain route towards Dharna. An official cited by the newspaper said the personnel retaliated and that around 40 rounds were fired during the exchange.

However, the newspaper also noted that the deaths had not been officially confirmed as a terrorist attack at the time of its report. The distinction matters: an exchange of fire and missing service weapons provide important investigative leads, but the identity of the attackers and the complete sequence of events must still be established.

Congress raises the ‘mistaken identity’ possibility

The political controversy erupted after Tariq Hameed Karra called for a comprehensive investigation into the killings and questioned the competing accounts circulating about the incident.

According to reports of his remarks, Karra referred to an account suggesting that the two SPOs had gone hunting with firearms and were returning in civilian clothes when they may have been mistaken for militants by security personnel.

He questioned the circumstances in which the men reportedly crossed security pickets while travelling towards the area and how they subsequently came under fire.

Karra’s central demand was that investigators should not restrict their inquiry to one explanation before establishing the facts.

He also accused the BJP of attempting to give the incident a communal colour, arguing that the matter required a fair investigation rather than competing political narratives.

There is, however, an important distinction between asking investigators to examine a possibility and establishing that it actually happened.

There is no publicly confirmed investigative finding that the Army or any other security force mistakenly shot the two SPOs. The hunting account and the suggestion of mistaken identity remain claims raised in the political debate. They have not been established through publicly available forensic findings or an official investigative conclusion.

The question can be examined through duty records, deployment orders, the clothing worn by the personnel, eyewitness accounts, ballistic evidence and the statements of those stationed at nearby security posts.

Karra’s demand for an impartial probe is a political position. It should not be presented as proof that security forces were responsible for the killings.

Sunil Sharma rejects Congress’s allegation

BJP leader and Leader of Opposition Sunil Sharma strongly objected to Karra’s remarks, accusing the Congress leader of spreading misinformation and attempting to shift responsibility from suspected militants to security forces.

Sharma maintained that Babi Chand and Rashpal Kumar were on official duty with the SOG and were travelling towards an Army post in the Dharna-Marwah area to relieve personnel deployed there.

He rejected the suggestion that the men were out hunting and described the allegation as an insult to their service and their grieving families.

The BJP leader also pointed to the missing weapons, magazines and ammunition, as well as reports of Pakistani-origin armour-piercing cartridges recovered from the scene.

According to Sharma, these circumstances supported the suspected militant-attack theory rather than the possibility of mistaken identity.

He further accused Karra of contradicting the Congress party’s earlier position, claiming that the party had initially described the incident as a terrorist attack before questioning the role of security forces.

Sharma demanded that Karra withdraw his remarks and apologise to the families and security personnel.

The BJP’s argument reflects the suspicion expressed in initial reporting about militant involvement. But the final conclusion must come from the investigation, not from political statements.

The recovery of ammunition described as Pakistani-origin also requires careful interpretation. Its reported origin, the weapon from which it was fired and the identity of the person who used it are separate questions that require forensic examination.

A significant contradiction: BJP leaders also question police deployment

One of the most important developments in the controversy is that questions about the circumstances of the killings are not limited to Congress.

Sunil Sharma himself publicly criticised the police administration over the operational decision to send the two SPOs through difficult terrain to assist an Army base.

During his interaction with Jammu Zone Inspector General of Police Tejinder Singh in Kiyar, Sharma questioned why the two personnel had been sent on the assignment carrying an INSAS rifle and a .303 rifle.

He also questioned why personnel from a nearby security establishment were not used for the task and criticised what he described as poor operational planning.

Kishtwar MLA Shagun Parihar also raised concerns about the deployment of SPOs outside the area where they were ordinarily posted. She sought an inquiry into the preparation of the duty roster and questioned the response of senior police officers following the killings.

These developments are significant because they reveal a separate issue from the Congress allegation.

Even if investigators ultimately establish that militants killed the two SPOs, the police administration may still have to answer questions about deployment arrangements, the route selected, the availability of security support and the risks associated with the assignment.

A militant attack and possible administrative lapses are not mutually exclusive explanations. Both can be investigated without prejudging the responsibility of any individual or institution.

Why were the two SPOs sent from Kiyar to Dharna?

A detailed report by The Indian Express has brought the deployment arrangement into sharper focus.

According to officials cited by the newspaper, the two personnel were part of a four-member SOG post in Kiyar. Since the previous month, two personnel at a time were reportedly being assigned week-long duty at a Temporary Operational Base in Dharna, in the adjoining Marwah area.

The assignment involved assisting Rashtriya Rifles personnel operating in the mountainous region.

The route itself was challenging. An official quoted by The Indian Express described the journey as a seven-to-eight-hour trek through dense forest and mountainous terrain. Personnel had to cross a mountain ridge, descend towards Dharna and climb again towards the Army base.

The newspaper also reported that Dharna had its own SOG unit, raising questions about why personnel from Kiyar were being sent there.

This is now one of the most important administrative questions in the case.

Investigators and the police leadership need to establish who authorised the deployment, why the arrangement was considered necessary and whether the risks associated with the route were adequately assessed.

The duty roster, deployment orders and operational instructions should provide a clearer picture of the decision-making process.

Babi Chand had reportedly raised concerns about repeated deployment

The concerns surrounding the deployment became more serious after reports emerged that Babi Chand had expressed apprehensions about being repeatedly assigned duty outside his regular area of posting.

According to The Indian Express, family members and local residents said Chand had reservations about the weekly deployment at the Dharna base.

Villagers reportedly told senior police officers during their visit to Kiyar that the two SPOs were returning after completing a week-long duty when they encountered people in the forest who asked where they were coming from and who would replace them.

This account, attributed to local residents, raises another question: whether the attackers had prior knowledge of the personnel’s movements.

It does not establish that information was leaked or that anyone deliberately facilitated the killings. But investigators should examine whether the deployment schedule was known outside the security establishment and whether the two personnel had been specifically targeted.

The absence of reliable mobile connectivity in Kiyar also complicates the picture. The village has been described as a communication shadow zone, making routine communication and emergency response more difficult.

These circumstances make the examination of local security arrangements especially important.

Families demand CBI probe and accountability

The families of the slain SPOs have demanded a CBI investigation into the killings, expressing dissatisfaction with the circumstances surrounding the incident and the security arrangements in the region.

Ramesh Kumar, brother of Babi Chand, told The Thursday Times that one of the deceased was his brother and the other his nephew. He questioned why the two men had been assigned duty outside their own area when security posts already existed in the adjoining region.

The families have also raised concerns about the declining security presence in Kiyar.

According to relatives quoted in media reports, around 45 security posts had been established in the area after the August 2000 massacre, when eight residents were killed by militants. They claim that only a handful of personnel are now guarding the village.

The families have asked Lieutenant Governor Manoj Sinha to intervene and order a CBI inquiry into the latest killings and earlier attacks.

Their demand is not limited to identifying the attackers. They also want an examination of whether the security infrastructure was weakened over the years and whether the two SPOs were exposed to unnecessary risks.

It is important to clarify that a demand for a CBI investigation does not mean the case has been transferred to the agency. The investigation remains subject to the decisions of the competent authorities.

Kiyar’s history of violence adds to local fears

The latest killings have reopened painful memories in Kiyar, a remote settlement in the Dachhan area that has experienced militant violence in the past.

Local accounts cited by media reports recall the August 1, 2000 massacre, when eight residents were killed. Two more villagers were reportedly abducted and killed in 2004.

For families in the region, the deaths of Babi Chand and Rashpal Kumar are therefore not being viewed as an isolated incident.

They have renewed concerns about the security of villages located far from major administrative centres, particularly those surrounded by dense forests and difficult mountain routes.

The geographical challenges are substantial. Poor road connectivity, limited mobile coverage and long distances can delay emergency response and make it difficult for security agencies to maintain a continuous presence.

The Deputy Commissioner, Pankaj Kumar Sharma, reportedly assured the families that eligible dependants would be considered for compassionate appointments and that compensation admissible under government rules would be processed.

He also assured residents that road connectivity and mobile network coverage in Kiyar would be taken up with the concerned departments.

These commitments may provide some immediate relief, but the larger concern is whether the security infrastructure in vulnerable villages is adequate to prevent further attacks.

Missing weapons and reported Pakistani-origin ammunition: What do they establish?

The missing service weapons are among the most significant pieces of evidence being examined.

Reports state that an INSAS rifle and a .303 rifle, along with magazines and ammunition, were missing after the bodies were recovered.

Media reports also cited the recovery of empty cartridges described by officials as Pakistani-origin armour-piercing ammunition.

These details have strengthened the suspicion that militants may have attacked the two personnel and taken their weapons.

But the forensic findings will be crucial.

Investigators need to establish whether the recovered cartridges can be linked to a particular weapon, whether they match ammunition recovered in other incidents and whether the ballistic evidence supports the reported exchange of fire.

The missing firearms must also be traced. If they were taken by the attackers, their recovery could provide important evidence about the perpetrators and their network.

The investigation should establish:

  • The exact number and type of cartridges recovered.

  • Whether ballistic examination can identify the weapons used.

  • Whether the missing INSAS and .303 rifles were taken from the scene.

  • Whether the firing positions and bullet trajectories support the reported sequence of events.

  • Whether any communication records or eyewitness accounts help identify the attackers.

Until these findings are made public, the ammunition and missing weapons should be described as investigative evidence and leads, not as conclusive proof of who carried out the killings.

Mosque announcement allegation raises communal concerns

The controversy has taken another sensitive turn after BJP MLA Shagun Parihar reportedly alleged that an announcement at a local mosque preceded the killings and that information about the SPOs’ movements may have been leaked to militants.

The Telegraph reported that authorities had not confirmed these allegations.

Parihar’s remarks have raised concerns because they bring a religious institution and the local Muslim community into a case whose central facts remain under investigation.

The National Conference also criticised the BJP MLA’s remarks, accusing her of dragging a mosque and loudspeakers into the matter and potentially aggravating communal tensions.

The allegations require careful handling. If investigators find evidence that any individual or group provided information or logistical support to the attackers, the matter must be pursued under the law. But an allegation involving a mosque cannot be treated as an established fact without independent corroboration.

The same evidentiary standard must apply to every political claim surrounding the killings.

The danger is that a security investigation could become overshadowed by communal accusations before the facts are established. That would risk increasing tensions in a region where residents have already experienced repeated violence.

Political fallout spreads beyond Congress and BJP

The controversy has also drawn the National Conference into the debate.

NC leaders have criticised the remarks made by BJP representatives, particularly the allegations involving a mosque and the wider suggestion that a particular community was being targeted.

The party has argued that sensitive security incidents should not be used to create communal divisions.

At the same time, BJP leaders have questioned the police administration publicly, including in the presence of senior officers. Their criticism has focused on deployment decisions, the security arrangements in Kiyar and the response following the killings.

This has created an unusual political situation: Congress is questioning the possibility of mistaken identity, the BJP is rejecting that allegation while criticising police operational decisions, and the NC is warning against communalising the incident.

The political positions differ, but one issue should command agreement across parties: the families deserve a credible investigation and the public deserves an evidence-based account of what happened.

What investigators must establish now

The investigation must move beyond political statements and establish a reliable sequence of events.

First, investigators need to verify the exact duty assigned to the two SPOs, their departure time, the route they travelled and the personnel responsible for preparing and approving the deployment roster.

Second, the accounts of Army personnel, police staff, local residents and civilians who may have been travelling along the route must be examined.

Third, the forensic evidence must establish the direction and sequence of firing, the weapons used and whether the missing service firearms were taken away.

Fourth, investigators should examine whether the two personnel had been specifically targeted, whether anyone had prior knowledge of their movements and whether local assistance was provided to the attackers.

Finally, the families’ concerns about the deployment arrangement and the security presence in Kiyar should be addressed separately from the question of who fired the shots.

An impartial investigation does not mean accepting every allegation. It means examining each claim against evidence, regardless of whether it comes from a political leader, a police official or a family member.

The real issue is accountability, not political point-scoring

The killing of Babi Chand and Rashpal Kumar has exposed several layers of concern in Kishtwar: the continuing security threat in remote mountain areas, the vulnerability of local police personnel, the difficulty of maintaining communication and security infrastructure, and the need for accountability in operational decisions.

The Congress allegation of mistaken identity remains unproven. The BJP’s rejection of that possibility is equally not a substitute for an investigative conclusion. The missing weapons and reported ammunition recovery are important leads, but the final responsibility must be established through forensic and other evidence.

The families’ questions about deployment are particularly important because they concern decisions that can be examined through official records. Their demand for a CBI probe also reflects a desire for an investigation they can trust.

For the administration, the challenge is twofold: identify and bring the attackers to justice, while also addressing legitimate questions about the security arrangements that preceded the deaths.

Two SPOs have lost their lives while performing duties in one of Kishtwar’s most difficult and vulnerable regions. Their families deserve more than political assurances and competing accusations. They deserve a transparent investigation that establishes who killed them, how it happened and whether any failure in the system left them exposed to danger.

Related Stories

View All »
Disclaimer Kashmir InFocus Editorial & Content Disclaimer

Kashmir InFocus (kashmirinfocus.com) is an independent online news and current affairs portal committed to credible, unbiased, and responsible digital journalism. The views, opinions, and analysis expressed in articles, guest columns, commentaries, and letters are solely those of the respective authors and contributors and do not necessarily reflect the official editorial stance or policy of Kashmir InFocus or Kashmir eServices. While we make every endeavor to ensure accuracy, timeliness, and factual integrity, Kashmir InFocus assumes no liability for errors, omissions, or third-party content. Readers are encouraged to verify facts independently. All trademarks, registered logos, and copyrighted material cited belong to their respective owners.