Kashmir InFocus
Beyond headlines, into lives: News that matters to you
Live Desk November 21, 2026

Is mosque integral to Islam? Query may delay Babri case

Adjudication of the politically sensitive Ayodhya land dispute case will be delayed as the Supreme Court on Friday said it will first decide whether the apex court’s 1994 decision that a “mosque is not an essential part of Islam” needs to be re-examined by a Constitution bench.
A bench of Chief Justice Dipak Misra and Justices Ashok Bhushan and S Abdul Nazeer said it would examine whether a five-judge bench was required to go into the question of whether a mosque was integral to Islam, but they turned down the demand that the 70-year-old legal battle between Hindu and Muslim communities over ownership of the nearly 3 acres of Babri Masjid-Ram Janmabhoomi disputed land be also referred to a larger bench.
Senior advocate Rajeev Dhavan, representing one of the original plaintiffs, MSiddiq, now replaced by his legal heir after his death, said the entire case should be referred to a Constitution bench.
“Why should only one part and not the entire case be referred to a Constitution bench,” he asked. Lawyers appearing for those who have claimed the Ayodhya site for construction of a Ram temple objected to reopening of the ‘Ismail Faruqui case’ of 1994 and said there was no need to refer any issue to a larger bench.

“First, we must put the controversy (over whether mosque is essential to Islam) to an end,” said the bench, which had earlier referred to the decades-old legal battle as a mere “land dispute.”
The SC had said in its ‘Ismail Faruqui case’ of 1994, “A mosque is not an essential part of the practice of the religion of Islam and namaz (prayer) by Muslims can be offered anywhere, even in the open. Accordingly, its acquisition is not prohibited by the provisions in the Constitution of India.”
Dhavan, in his two-hour-long argument, contended that the Faruqui case was wrongly decided by the apex court and the verdict contradicted an earlier SC judgment. “A mosque is forever. It does not lose its significance and it remains a place of worship even if it is demolished,” Dhavan said.

Related Stories

View All »
Disclaimer Kashmir InFocus Editorial & Content Disclaimer

Kashmir InFocus (kashmirinfocus.com) is an independent online news and current affairs portal committed to credible, unbiased, and responsible digital journalism. The views, opinions, and analysis expressed in articles, guest columns, commentaries, and letters are solely those of the respective authors and contributors and do not necessarily reflect the official editorial stance or policy of Kashmir InFocus or Kashmir eServices. While we make every endeavor to ensure accuracy, timeliness, and factual integrity, Kashmir InFocus assumes no liability for errors, omissions, or third-party content. Readers are encouraged to verify facts independently. All trademarks, registered logos, and copyrighted material cited belong to their respective owners.